Corrine Fusso
October 11, 2016 - After leading post-recession spending growth, affluent U.S. consumers1 have pulled back on spending in recent years. A key consumer segment, the affluent represent 20 percent of U.S. households but account for nearly 40 percent of consumer credit spending.
Since 2012, non-affluent consumers have played a more important role in driving spending growth, benefitting from strong job growth in lower- and middle-income wage tiers and disproportionate gains from low gas prices. During that period, affluent spending lagged as much as five percentage points behind non-affluent spending growth. Non-affluent consumers led spending growth since mid 2012.
Three main reasons were identified for the slowdown in affluent spending growth:
- Affluent consumer spending closely tracks with inflation. Lower prices actually cause a reduction in affluent spending and the affluent are more likely to pocket the savings from a drop in prices. Non-affluent consumers, on the other hand, typically spend their windfall.
- Negative wealth effects from weak stock gains have weighed on affluent consumers, who hold most of the stock wealth. Stock market volatility has less impact on non-affluent consumers, whose wealth is more closely tied to home ownership. Non-affluent spending has increased with recent steady gains in home values. One clue to the affluent spending dilemma: the Visa Luxury Spending Index, which shows a strong correlation between the S&P 500 and spending at luxury stores, has stagnated over the past 18 months due to limited stock market growth and volatility.
- Affluent baby boomers are spending less. Most boomers (now aged 52 to 70) are past their peak spending years—spending peaks on average at age 46, but slightly later for the affluent (age 54). As boomers reign in their spending and prepare for retirement, they leave a void that cannot be filled by Generation X, a smaller population group.
Affluent spending—and spending in general—will remain under pressure until millennials approach their peak spending years in the 2020s.
